|
Post by beaverbeliever on Sept 30, 2017 23:29:42 GMT -8
If only there was someway to know how 3M might fare against a UW defense....
Oh, wait, we all saw it last season. Not good - and their defense is even better now.
|
|
|
Post by kersting13 on Sept 30, 2017 23:32:26 GMT -8
Nevada scored 14 points late to make a game of it against a big sky team. Keep making excuses. The reality is that there are at least two decent starting QBs in D-I football that our coaches intentionally ran off. We currently have no viable D-I QB on our roster. The coaching staff chose to keep DG as a competitor for the starting QB job on this team. He's working on a 6-game starting streak of 0 TD passes. His 3.2 yards per pass attempt today is amazingly worse than the 4.5 he compiled last year. That's beyond bad.
|
|
|
Post by kersting13 on Sept 30, 2017 23:35:23 GMT -8
If only there was someway to know how 3M might fare against a UW defense.... Oh, wait, we all saw it last season. Not good - and their defense is even better now. Why are you even attempting this argument? 3M is undoubtedly 5x the QB DG is. It's not even debatable. And our coaches chose DG over 3M. Pitiful.
|
|
|
Post by drunkandstoopidbeav on Sept 30, 2017 23:39:40 GMT -8
A shame he quit. He'd be playing the rest of the year in the PAC 12. It's a shame that our coach is too stupid to evaluate QB talent. The mishandling of the QB position in his tenure is indefensible. Don't try to frame it as 3M's abandoning us, this coaching staff is the one that abandoned us. The biggest issue with our coaching staff right off the bat was they weren't willing to stick with decisions or a plan. Seth was arguably our best QB of this era, 3M was arguably right in there.... a mistake or two and they're out. I assume the overall plan is not to change every time the wind changes, but it seems that is the way it has been. I've got the idea that our team is FULL of guys looking over their shoulders. If you read a 3M article from today or yesterday it mentions players looking over their shoulders... I'm pretty sure he's not talking about the team he's actually currently on.
|
|
|
Post by kersting13 on Sept 30, 2017 23:42:23 GMT -8
It's a shame that our coach is too stupid to evaluate QB talent. The mishandling of the QB position in his tenure is indefensible. Don't try to frame it as 3M's abandoning us, this coaching staff is the one that abandoned us. The biggest issue with our coaching staff right off the bat was they weren't willing to stick with decisions or a plan. Seth was arguably our best QB of this era, 3M was arguably right in there.... a mistake or two and they're out. I assume the overall plan is not to change every time the wind changes, but it seems that is the way it has been. I've got the idea that our team is FULL of guys looking over their shoulders. If you read a 3M article from today or yesterday it mentions players looking over their shoulders... I'm pretty sure he's not talking about the team he's actually currently on. Seth was certainly a better QB than the guy who was hand-picked to replace him.
|
|
|
Post by drunkandstoopidbeav on Sept 30, 2017 23:52:50 GMT -8
If only there was someway to know how 3M might fare against a UW defense.... Oh, wait, we all saw it last season. Not good - and their defense is even better now. Oh please. We at least had 325 yards of offense last year. Beats he heck out of our 185 this year. To top that off, this year's QB has a comparatively significantly higher amount of career starts and experience than McMaryion had when he faced UW last year.
|
|
|
Post by beavsaregood on Oct 1, 2017 0:23:04 GMT -8
Nevada scored 14 points late to make a game of it against a big sky team. Can you just give it up to McMaryion and Tedford? A well thought out game plan that was executed. A coach that can identify talent. A coach that can prepare a game plan to bring out the talent's positive traits. Talent that can understand and execute the game plan. Has this happened yet with Coach Andersen /Coach McNugget and their many QBs that kinda cycled through the program in their few years in Corvallis?
|
|
|
Post by nabeav on Oct 1, 2017 5:35:13 GMT -8
Important to note that the opponent (Nevada) got boat raced by Big Sky bottom feeder Idaho State. If you can honestly tell me you think Garretson would have put up similar numbers vs. Nevada, I will allow this. Garretson was 15-30 for 172 with no TDs and an INT vs. Idaho State last year.
|
|
|
Post by osulax24 on Oct 1, 2017 6:23:25 GMT -8
Time for Collins back at QB, DG just can't make a downfield completion and really isn't a special runner
|
|
|
Post by seastape on Oct 1, 2017 7:54:35 GMT -8
A shame he quit. He'd be playing the rest of the year in the PAC 12. What makes you think that? CGA made it clear that 3M was behind Garretson on the depth chart and Garretson is not injured. There is also no proof whatsoever that CGA would NOT put in Blount if Garretson got injured, even if it meant burning Blount's redshirt year. 3M made the right decision for himself. I'm happy for the guy.
|
|
|
Post by kersting13 on Oct 1, 2017 7:58:46 GMT -8
Time for Collins back at QB, DG just can't make a downfield completion and really isn't a special runner If you think about it, CGA has basically torpedoed his career for his obsession with DG. - based on 2015 practices, he decided to move Collins to WR in order to promote DG to 2016 starter. - DG played so poorly in 2016, he need 2 season-ending injuries to get 3M into the starting role, where he proved to be a good QB - 2017, we all know the story of DG always being mentioned in the starting mix with Luton & 3M, even though we have 2016 to look at, leading to 3Ms departure. DG over Seth and DG over 3M (twice) are defining decisions in CGAs tenure. One thing is for sure, DG must be one TOUGH SOB. He can probably do the Tyler Durden "lye kiss" without even flinching. SaveSave
|
|
|
Post by RenoBeaver on Oct 1, 2017 8:01:27 GMT -8
If only there was someway to know how 3M might fare against a UW defense.... Oh, wait, we all saw it last season. Not good - and their defense is even better now. Why are you even attempting this argument? 3M is undoubtedly 5x the QB DG is. It's not even debatable. And our coaches chose DG over 3M. Pitiful. 3M is 10X the QB DG is. DG doesn't even qualify to be labeled a Division I QB. He is simply awful.
3M is 5X the QB CGA chose to start over him, but at least Luton has legit Division I skills, which unfortunately will never bear fruit playing for these clowns.
BTW, hire Tedford tomorrow, I'll take his 8 win limit. In fact give me ANYONE in the MWC right now over this staff, who is the worst coach in the league, because they will do better than CGA and squad.
|
|
|
Post by nforkbeav on Oct 1, 2017 8:17:33 GMT -8
If only there was someway to know how 3M might fare against a UW defense.... Oh, wait, we all saw it last season. Not good - and their defense is even better now. He actually played at UW this year. 63% completion and 113 rating compared to our QB at home, 50% completion and 78 rating Fresno State scored more on UW at UW than we did at home coming off a bye week.
|
|
|
Post by baseba1111 on Oct 1, 2017 8:20:18 GMT -8
If only there was someway to know how 3M might fare against a UW defense.... Oh, wait, we all saw it last season. Not good - and their defense is even better now. Ahhh... another thing there is no way to judge. But, you might want to take a peek at who UW lost of their D from last year. Their D is only better statistically because of who've they played this year. But keep defending GAG and his decisions... its funny the exists ands rhetoric you come up with. If there was only a way to know if we could be in a game this year? If there was only a way to know if a GAG team could win on the road... any time? If there was ANY way to know GAG coached team in year 3 could give a 1-11 team from last year with 50+ new players on the roster and his former starting QB a decent game? Oh ya... we do know...
|
|
|
Post by baseba1111 on Oct 1, 2017 8:24:38 GMT -8
Time for Collins back at QB, DG just can't make a downfield completion and really isn't a special runner If you think about it, CGA has basically torpedoed his career for his obsession with DG. - based on 2015 practices, he decided to move Collins to WR in order to promote DG to 2016 starter. - DG played so poorly in 2016, he need 2 season-ending injuries to get 3M into the starting role, where he proved to be a good QB - 2017, we all know the story of DG always being mentioned in the starting mix with Luton & 3M, even though we have 2016 to look at, leading to 3Ms departure. DG over Seth and DG over 3M (twice) are defining decisions in CGAs tenure. One thing is for sure, DG must be one TOUGH SOB. He can probably do the Tyler Durden "lye kiss" without even flinching. SaveSaveNot so sure about that toughness statement... Lyle must have cringed in embarrassment on DG's "attempted" block on the poorly called reverse to Seth.
|
|